Glass or silicone baby bottle: which to choose
A glass baby bottle has no plastic, doesn't hold on to smells and lasts for years as long as it doesn't break. A silicone one is unbreakable, light and soft in your hand and in your baby's mouth. Both are safe if they are good quality. Here we explain how they differ, who each one suits best and what to look for before you buy.
Glass, silicone or plastic baby bottle: a quick comparison
| Glass | Silicone | Plastic (PP) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | Heavier | Light | Light |
| Breaks | Yes, if dropped | No | No |
| Smells and stains | Doesn't absorb them | Can absorb them over time | Can scratch and absorb them |
| Very hot water | Copes well | Copes well | Better not to make up feeds with boiling water |
| Feel | Hard and cold | Soft and warm | Hard |
| Baby holds it | Harder | Easy | Easy |
Glass baby bottle: pros and cons
The glass in baby bottles is usually borosilicate glass, the same kind used in laboratory and oven dishes. It withstands changes in temperature and doesn't release anything into the milk.
Pros:
- It contains no plastic or bisphenols.
- It doesn't absorb smells, tastes or stains, not even with formula milk.
- It can be sterilised with no problem and lasts for years.
- You can easily see how much milk there is, and whether anything is left inside when you wash it.
Cons:
- It is heavier, especially when full. It is tiring to hold for a long feed and your baby takes longer to hold it alone.
- It can break or chip if dropped. You need to check it and throw it away if it has a crack or a chipped piece.
- It feels colder and harder.
- To take out and about, you need a silicone sleeve to protect it.
Silicone baby bottle: pros and cons
The silicone used in baby bottles is food grade: a flexible, bisphenol-free material that withstands the heat of the steriliser and the dishwasher.
Pros:
- It doesn't break, even if dropped.
- It is light and soft, so your baby grips it more easily.
- Its warm, soft feel is closer to skin. Many mums who breastfeed and also give the odd bottle prefer it for that reason.
- It withstands hot water, the steriliser and the dishwasher.
Cons:
- Over time it can pick up a little smell or colour, especially with formula milk. You can avoid this by washing it soon after every feed.
- It usually costs a little more than plastic.
What about plastic baby bottles?
The plastic baby bottles sold in Europe are made of polypropylene (PP) or other BPA-free plastics: bisphenol A has been banned in baby bottles in the European Union since 2011. They are light and cheap. With use they scratch, and residue and smells collect in the scratches, so it is best to replace them sooner.
A study published in Nature Food in 2020 found that polypropylene baby bottles release plastic microparticles when formula is prepared with very hot water and shaken. It is not yet known whether this has any effect on health, but if you use plastic it is better not to pour boiling water straight into the bottle. You can find more information about BPA in our article BPA-free baby bottles: what it means.
Which bottle should you choose: glass or silicone?
- If you breastfeed and also give the odd bottle: what matters most is the teat, not the material of the bottle. A teat with a shape and flow similar to your breast helps your baby switch from one to the other without problems.
- If you bottle-feed at home and want zero plastic: glass is a good option. Pair it with a sleeve.
- If you are out and about a lot, or your baby already wants to hold it alone: silicone is better. It doesn't break and it weighs less.
- If you can't decide: many families have a glass bottle for home and a silicone one for going out.
Our bottle: silicone and a teat shaped like your breast
The Happymami bottle is made of food-grade, BPA-free silicone, in both the bottle and the teat. It was created by midwives to protect breastfeeding: the teat is designed to match the shape of your breast and the length, diameter and elasticity of your nipple, so that your baby can switch between breast and bottle. It has a double anti-colic system and can go in the dishwasher and the steriliser.
How to look after a glass or silicone baby bottle
- Wash it straight after the feed with hot water and washing-up liquid, and a brush used only for baby bottles. That way it doesn't pick up smells.
- Check the glass every time you wash it. If it has a crack or a chipped piece, throw it away.
- Change the teats when they are sticky, cracked or misshapen. You will find the guidelines in when to change bottle teats.
- Sterilise as your midwife or paediatrician advises. We explain it step by step in how to clean and sterilise a baby bottle.
Frequently asked questions
Is a glass or a plastic baby bottle better?
Glass has no plastic, doesn't absorb smells and lasts longer; plastic weighs less and doesn't break. If you want to avoid plastic and don't drop things, glass is better. If you want something light and unbreakable without plastic, choose silicone.
Is a glass baby bottle anti-colic?
The material doesn't make a bottle anti-colic. What helps is a valve that lets air in and a suitable teat flow. Read our article on the anti-colic baby bottle.
Can a silicone baby bottle be sterilised?
Yes. Food-grade silicone withstands boiling water, the steam steriliser and the dishwasher.
Which bottle is best for a newborn?
One with a slow-flow teat and, if you breastfeed, a shape similar to your breast. You will find a full comparison in the best baby bottles.
Sources: Commission Directive 2011/8/EU (ban on bisphenol A in baby bottles); Li D. et al., "Microplastic release from the degradation of polypropylene feeding bottles during infant formula preparation", Nature Food, 2020.
